KENAI PENINSULA BOROUGH
Proposal Evaluation for: Nikiski Emergency Escape Route Improvement Project
		Mike Tauriainen P.E.	McLane Consulting	Wm, J Nelson & Assoc.
Qualifications and	Evaluator 1	12	20	16
Experience of the  Firm	Evaluator 2	20	20	20
(0-20 points)	Evaluator 3	20	20	20
	TOTAL	52	60	56
Key Project Staff and	Evaluator 1	16	20	16
Sub-consultants	Evaluator 2	20	20	20
(0-20 points)	Evaluator 3	16	20	16
	TOTAL	52	60	52
Methodology/Approach	Evaluator 1	12	16	12
(0-25 points)	Evaluator 2	25	25	25
	Evaluator 3	25	20	20
	TOTAL	62	61	57
Available Resources/Firm	Evaluator 1	6	10	8
Location (0-10 points)	Evaluator 2	10	10	10
	Evaluator 3	8	8	10
	TOTAL	24	28	28
	Subtotal	190	209	193
Cost         (0-25 points)		25	24	22
(Formula Driven)
	TOTAL SCORE	215	233	215